Valuing Cryptocurrencies - An Approach

Valuing Cryptocurrencies - An Approach


There are well over 1,000 cryptocurrencies floating around right now, and it’s my sincere belief that many, if not most of them, will fail. This becomes especially evident when a little bit of thoughtful research is done, and one sees that many of them either have no realistic plans for success (beyond a pump-and-dump of the coin), and/or offer no meaningful value that is not already well represented in the crypto-space.  So how to tell them apart? Well, I’ll share my personal approach, which I hope you find interesting and maybe useful. I suspect that applying this methodology might lead one to ‘miss out’ on some rip-roaring rally on a coin that might otherwise have been speculated in, but hopefully it will also keep one from waking up one morning to discover the coin thought to be a sure thing for a quick in-and-out trade has dropped precipitously in value. Different people need different things to sleep at night. Diff'rent strokes for Diff'rent folks. 

Step 1: Ask (and attempt to answer the question) – Is the goal of this cryptocurrency to be considered money? In other words, does the coin hope to be considered a broad and fundamental unit of money/currency that will be used to effect value transfers?

The primary examples of coins that attempt to ‘be money’ are:
Bitcoin, Bitcoin cash, Litecoin, Dash & Monero.

The goal of eventually becoming money is potentially incredibly valuable. The prize is the displacement of a significant percentage of existing forms of money (namely, Fiat currencies issued by governments, whether they be dollars, euros, yen, etc.) and that achievement would be stupendous in its implications – both socially and financially.

The current measure of all transactional ‘money’ in the world (an economic measure called M3) is approximately $80 trillion. If any one of the 5 coins above mentioned are to be successful as ‘money’ and garner a significant share of M3, it would have astounding implications for the value of the coins. The (very rough) table below shows that ‘upside’ from current values should the individual coins achieve a 20% of M3 ‘market share’ range from ~50 times current value for Bitcoin, to over 2,600 times current value for Monero. This is in stark contrast to coins that do not aspire to be money which we will explore shortly.

(Please excuse the horrendously scrappy cut/paste for the below table.. the gist of it should be clear though)



So now we come to a fork in the road – was the answer to Step 1 a ‘yes’, or a ‘no’? If ‘yes’, then proceed to Step 2. If ‘no’, proceed to Step 3.

Step 2: Check the coin under consideration for its current and prospective ability to satisfy the criteria of ‘moneyness’.  

I won’t go into a full re-hash of the concept of moneyness here, as you can read plenty about it in TPOM and The Bitcoin Flaw, but in short, the coins need to satisfy the 4 main aspects of sound money – Store of Value, Unit of Account Medium of Exchange and Fungibility[1].

We check for its moneyness under the simple premise that if a coin lacks any critical aspect of moneyness, it will ultimately fail and hand the mantle of ‘money’ over to a coin that succeeds. My take on all the above mentioned coins (in case you didn't know) is that i far prefer Monero as the best candidate. In any case, you can decide for yourself and are free to disagree and/or hedge your bets.

The math though for valuation in this scenario becomes trivial (although determination of input values is not). If the coin in question passes the test for being surviving money, then we may apply the valuation technique as {[Expected % of M3] x [M3 Value] }/ [number of coins outstanding].. all present-valued.

Step 3: Determine what value is being created by the coin and/or coin ecosystem.

*Note: you should only be here in step 3 if you answered no to the question in Step 1. I realize that some people might make an argument for ETH being in both places, but I disagree for reasons I won’t expand on here. Feel free to email me if you’d like to discuss.

Since the coin we are now looking at is not a ‘money’ prospect, we can apply much more traditional valuation metrics – without needing to understand some bigger-picture and subtler aspects of global macroeconomics. Hooray!

We simply need to ask, what value is being created?

Let’s take what has been a contentious coin for me as an example: Ripple (technically XRP, the coin).
Ripple, as a medium of exchange that can facilitate lower cost cross-border transactions, offers the prospect for enormous value to be released. After all, there are many billions of dollars currently spent (and arguably wasted) in the current archaic and cumbersome international money transfer market. We can even ascribe theoretical dollars to it, so let’s do that:

Let’s say the Annual cross-border international transfer market is $200 trillion annually, and let’s further assume the average fee savings by replacing the old archaic systems with the disruption of blockchain-type processes will be a clean 5% - that’s $10 trillion a year!

So maybe this mean that Ripple’s coin, XRP, if Ripple were to garner a 100% market share should be worth $10 trillion?! Not so fast there cowboy.

Now that we’ve identified the potential value-creation/release aspect, we need to make a critical next-step jump – and this leads us to Step 4. Of course, if we haven’t been able to identify any monetary value being created at all, we can stop here and most likely abandon the coin from consideration.

Step 4: Ask – To WHERE and/or WHOM does the value created in Step 3 Accrue?

In Ripple’s case, most of the value accrues to two parties – competitive pressures will see to that – either the banks themselves who no longer have to bear the cost-burden of an antiquated system, or the customers who will experience much lower costs and fees.

But wait a minute – we are valuing a coin here – so the real question (between the lines) is something a little different.. let’s make this our step 5.

Step 5: Ask – How does value created by the coin/ecosystem/etc. necessarily accrue to the coin under question? And by how much?

Let’s stick with Ripple for the example.

I’ve never argued that Ripple wasn’t a good idea. While I still question the uptake and competitive response, and many people have enjoyed an ‘I told you so!’ after a few recent announcements and a big price move – I have yet to hear anyone address this Step 5 question (even though it has been asked of some people who claim to be the experts).

Just because a coin/currency/etc. creates value as a whole, for an investment in the coin to be based on solid fundamentals, there has to be a demonstration as to why the coin needs to be worth more.
Good news for XRP investors – I definitely see a scenario where it needs to maintain a value. The (potentially) bad news – that value could be a lot lower than current levels.

Rather than rewrite it, I’ll just quote my other post (the Postscript to ‘Goodbye to Ripple’… even leaving in my 2-glasses-of-wine snarky comment):

Most people (not all) have conceded that Ripple is not about being ‘money’, but a functional tool. In that case, we ought to value it on that metric – how much value is being created, and to where does it accrue?

Let’s use some numbers.

$207 trillion annual market size.
Assume evenly distributed, that’s about $500 billion moving a day.
There are 86,400 seconds in a day. Again, assuming smooth distribution if XRP was 100% used as transfer medium in the market, every 5 seconds (on average) it would have to move about $30 million. If we assume it needs that FULL balance to be held in 15 different currencies, that’s a required market float of 30million x 15 = $450 MILLION (that’s million with an M). Heck – let’s say that we’re off by an order or magnitude somehow and multiply by 10. Now we’re back to billions - $4.5 billion – or less than half the current capitalization.

Is there a fault in that example? I honestly don’t know. I just spent 5 minutes working it out and have had a couple of glasses of wine. My point is, talking about value being created and that same value accruing to the benefit of the actual coins is talking about two very different things. It’s the same thing as a company you might love, but whose stock is awfully priced.

While people may love-love-love XRP as a trade right now, if it is going to maintain its value, it has to be demonstrated in theory perhaps, but ultimately in practice why it needs to be valued more than, for instance the $4.5 billion in my example above. Otherwise its value is being propped up by raw speculation - not buttressed by any fundamental value. This in turn leaves it subject to significant (and perhaps inevitable) correction risk.

I didn’t really want this to be about Ripple, so I’ll just add one more thing before moving on – in the cryptomania we’re seeing today, going up in value is not proof that a fundamental valuation is sound. Maybe there are other fundamental justifications for why XRP needs to be valued where it is (outside of a speculation medium). If there is/are, I have yet to see it/them. If you genuinely see a way to correct me, then by all means, don’t waste time leaving Anonymous blog comments – send it to me and convince me. I guarantee I’ll issue an ‘eating my hat’ mea-culpa report highlighting the error(s) in my (now current) thinking. 

So – back to how value accrues to a coin in general.

If you cannot identify how value must accrue to a coin (whether as a function of facilitating a smart-contract, money transfer, or otherwise) then you are very likely veering away from investing and toward speculation.

Hey, there’s nothing wrong with gambling/speculation per se. I’ve personally never been really good at it. Some people are. But before you convince yourself that you are blessed with innate intuitive trading sense, consider this: All those glorious and impressive Las Vegas hotels and monuments were paid for by losers – and though I’ve personally known a few paper-millionaires in the dot-com boom, each of them quietly went back to their day jobs a few years later.

As the saying goes: Bulls make money. Bears make money. Pigs get slaughtered.

Good luck!
Izzy


EDIT: March 2018: if you've read up until this point, then hopefully you have enjoyed it. Considering how many hits this page gets, i thought i would mention that if you are interested in engaging me for cryptocurrency education or advisory, please feel free to email me. I've always happy to have a chat.





[1] Technically speaking fungibility really falls under the purview of Medium of Exchange. I’m happy to leave it as a 4th criterion though given it’s incredible importance and difficulty of grasp for many, which I think may be remedied by calling extra attention to it.

Comments

  1. Yodse ecosystem overview

    Yodse's main purposes

    The platform yodse aims to become the largest Internet ecosystem for the most convenient, rapid and profitable interaction of enterprises in the field of production of industrial product groups in the markets of Russia, CIS, South-East Asia, and later in Europe and the United States. This global, decentralized and transparent B2B / B2C trading platform has all the advantages of blockchain technology and thus provides manufacturers with the most convenient communication with their wholesalers and retail buyers. The scale, high-tech products and convenient user-friendly tools within the ecosystem will allow small and medium-sized businesses to achieve better results and gain practical benefit.

    Challenges that yodse ecosystem solves

    Yodse project is aimed at solving a number of problems related to direct, convenient, rapid and profitable "manufacturer-consumer" interaction. The transparent ecosystem yodse focuses on the protection consumers from losses, connected with the lack of guarantees from manufacturers and abundance of poor-quality goods. By establishing communication mechanisms, buyers will be provided with technical support, and manufacturers will receive quality feedback. The platform will reduce the delivery time and enable consumers to purchase goods without intermediaries. Excessive costs of manufacturers for outdated marketing technologies and high fees of goods placement on existing e-commerce platforms will become history. The YODSE system offers its users low fees and creates conditions for easy access of small businesses to e-commerce and international markets.

    Advantages of using ecosystem (platform) yodse for manufacturers

    The yodse electronic platform and its tools allow businesses, operating in the production of industrial product groups to find their retail and wholesale customers and to provide direct sales without intermediaries. The system helps to set up a mechanism for communication with clients, enhance the transparency of transactions, perform transparent management and control in the process of delivery and payments, and expand the customer base, maximize the volume of goods turnover and net profit. In addition, owing to the global system based on the blockchain technology, small and medium-sized businesses will be able to solve the problems of entering new promising markets, as well as significantly improve the competitiveness of manufactured industrial products.

    Advantages of using ecosystem (platform) yodse for consumers

    Yodse project gives huge advantages for users while searching and purchasing industrial products group, motor vehicles, production, road construction, mining and agricultural machinery, material handling equipment, rigging arrangement, turbines, equipment for ventilation and air conditioning, pumps, compressors, bearings and others. Direct prices from manufacturer without intermediaries allow to maximize profit and users feedbacks and quality technical support from manufacturers will enable consumers to learn more about the product and make sure of its quality.

    Benefits for users from yodse ecosystem scaling

    Joining of a number of manufacturers of industrial groups of goods to the yodse system will make it possible to conclude a lot of mutually beneficial, multimillion contracts. As the yodse platform dynamically develops and scales, there will be a gradual increase in the number of offices being opened in many regions in order to provide quality and continuous technical support to users in other countries and maintain the brand. The scaling of ecosystem will enhance the frequency of use of the platform in a number of countries, which will increase the number of users, thereby facilitating the establishment of export-import transactions between countries and, as a result, increase sales volumes of manufacturers. Manufacturers, who sign in earlier than others, will take the advantages of being pioneers in new markets.

    https://yodse.io/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Investment plansPROMO PACKAGE ?? BASIC Invest $70 earn $600 Invest $100 earn $1000  Invest $200 earn $2,000  Invest $300 earn $3,500  Invest $400 earn $4,500  Invest $500 earn $6,000 
      ?? PRO  Invest $1,000 earn $15,000  Invest $2,000 earn $25,000  Invest $3,000 earn $35,000  Invest $4,000 earn $45,000  Invest $5,000 earn $60,000  Invest $10,000 earn $100,000. 
      ?? PREMIUM  1BTC earn 5BTC  2BTC earn 10BTC  3BTC earn 16BTC  4BTC earn 22BTC  5BTC earn 30BTC. 
      ALL RETURNS ARE SCHEDULE, FOR 12 HOURS, UPON CONFIRMATION OF PAYMENTS.
      MODE OF PAYMENT. Any, Suitable For Investors, But Terms and Conditions Apply.
      ??HURRY NOW!!! Refer a Friend or Family member to invest same time, and Receive an instant $50 Reward. 
      To set up an INVESTMENT PLAN, Contact Admin: totalinvestmentcompany@gmail.com
      WhatsApp: +1(929)390-8581
      https://www.facebook.com/pg/Total-Investment-221964325813140/about/
      https://t.me/totalinvestment

      Delete
  2. Thanks for sharing...
    You might have a doubt that why should you use Bitcoin to make and receive payments rather than using paper currency for transactions. Well, there are many benefits that you can enjoy if you start using Bitcoin. Now there might be some Ganesh Godse but he was the man with all positive energy and dynamic personality.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice article and thanks for sharing your knowledge.
    cryptocurrency statistics

    ReplyDelete
  4. Earn Bitcoins while using Google Chrome. Add CryptoTab to your Chrome and start earning Bitcoins. Get CryptoTab - Easy way for Bitcoin Mining. Develop the network and get your rewards! Invite your friends, family and associates by your personal link and make many times more money! Get more than 1 BTC!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing...
    Bitcoins are worthy as they are used as a form of money. Pritesh Saitwal negative reviews gives an idea about Bitcoin prices, they are highly volatile. Though there are many Pritesh Saitwal spam reviews but they play a vital role in BTCmonk,s huge success. All the characteristics of money are present in Bitcoin.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for sharing this information.
    CoinOrbisCap is the best user-friendly financial app who take digital currency seriously. Gives you quick access to crypto prices, market cap, coin chart, crypto news on over 1500 currencies.

    Download here for FREE!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice post! Live Active ICO 2018That is an extremely nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this season! ICO List 2018 Thanks a lot for the informative post. Active ICO 2018

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ethereumpro.net provides cheapest way to convert ether to paypal usd where any one can withdraw and transfer crypto coins ethereum to paypal with no minimum amount required
    System works automatic with high speed.

    Follow the link below:

    https://www.ethereumpro.net/exchange-ethereum-to-paypal.php

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ethereum is the most famous cryptocurrency and a platform which is consists of decartelized blockchain technology.
    ethereum to paypal service is here.
    The hhtp://www.ethereumpro.net is a reliable and fast Ethereum conversion website that facilitate its users from all over the world.
    ethereum to paypal exchange service where you can easily convert your ethereum to paypal.


    http://www.ethereumpro.net

    ReplyDelete
  10. Exchange ethereum to paypal instantly

    ethereumpro.net best website to exchange your ethereum to paypal and other currencies.there are many websites are working but this is the
    best website.highly trusted site and have thousands of satisfied customers

    https://www.ethereumpro.net/

    ReplyDelete
  11. The visit our website in a secure website and not charging any fee. It is the best source of exchanging your ether because it provides best market rates for the selling and converting of ether into paypal. This is an automatic website and complete the whole process with in minutes and saves time of clients. It will provide the detail analysis of the current and historical prices of Ethereum to the users for their profitable decision making.

    ReplyDelete
  12. CryptoCurrencies News
    GrubleTrang - Awesome Things You Can Learn From Studying Internet

    ReplyDelete
  13. Codeninja.pk is web development company in lahore,Providing the greatest value possible while providing website packages which cover all of your needs.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Codeninja.pk is web development company in lahore,Allow potential clients to understand your strengths.Establish yourself as a leader within the industry.

    ReplyDelete
  15. ijin post yah ..
    E D E N POKER adalah situs judi game online terbaik dengan ranting kemenangan TERBESAR yang pernah ada. kartu bagus , banyak bonus, mudah menang, dan masi banyak hadiah kejutan lain nya juga
    Mari buruan bergabung bersama kami hanya di E D E N POKER
    www(.)edenpoker(.)xyz
    GUDANG PROMO IDN POKER
    Agen Bandar Poker Terpercaya
    Bandar Poker IDN
    Poker IDN Terbaik
    Agen Judi Uang Asli
    Agen Judi Terbaik Di Indonesia
    Agen Judi Deposit Murah
    Info Poker IDN Terbaik

    ReplyDelete
  16. Turn your 300$ into 1000$ in 42 hours and you don't need to refer anyone except yourself ask me how
    If you have a BLOCKCHAIN wallet
    coin.ph wallet or coinbase wallet. it doesn't matter what wallet you own
    You can make $3000 BTC with your phone or pc in a day only if you invest now with the right person. skylink technology is the best in the bitcoin industry as they have come up with a way and technology to get your bitcoin doubled in hours. am sharing this because i don't want to be the only one benefiting from this, i want you to too as well so hurry up and get in touch with them and make your deposit
    mail: skylinktechnes@yahoo.com or whatsapp: +1(213)785-1553 or website: https://skylinktechnes.wixsite.com/info

    ReplyDelete
  17. This widget shows the exchange rate for a chosen currency pair. The user selects the base currency and the quotation currency from a list in the widget settings. It possible to choose from more than 150 world currencies. The market value is automatically updated in a time interval or after a click on the course. To know practically please visit here https://fxwidget.io/

    ReplyDelete
  18. Mind Capital – Inversión en Criptomonedas

    Mind.Capital es un novedoso sistema de inversión en criptomonedas encabezado por Gonzalo García-Pelayo junto a un equipo de expertos en inversiones, matemáticas y tecnología.

    El método desarrollado por Mind Capital, después de mucho tiempo de investigación del blockchain es capaz de estudiar y analizar a tiempo real la evolución de los principales criptoactivos. De esta forma, encontrarán el momento idóneo para realizar órdenes de compra y/o venta.
    To know more Click Here

    ReplyDelete

Post a comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Bitcoin Flaw: Monero Rising

Monero Valuation – Update and Refocus